When Fabio Capello resigned as England manager in February, it seemed that the overwhelming opinion and support from football experts and fans alike was towards Harry Rednapp taking over at the helm.
Simply – there was nobody else that sprung to mind and that was in such a position to be able to take the job. However, for one reason or another the timing of Capello's resignation was awkward. First of all, coming in mid-season as it did and Harry's Spurs challenging to regain a Champions League spot meant that Rednapp probably did not want to leave a job only half done. By sticking with Tottenham – at least until the end of the season means that if he were to become the new nation's manager that he would have little time to prepare for Euro 2012 concentrating on purely England.
In other qualifying countries right now, their managers are 100% focused on what lies ahead this summer and on nothing else. They are talking to all of the top coaches, getting weekly fitness reports, talking to and watching players on a weekly basis that will all figure into their plans this summer. If Rednapp does this, then he literally will only be able to look at a list of players that he already knows and pretty much pick a squad in the same way that the majority of us would.
What is he going to do any differently than anybody else at this stage? What tactics is he going to try and implement in such a short time space for no real preparation? Surely if this is the way that the FA decide to go then Rednapp will be nothing short of just a face this summer being used to just keep the squad ticking over and hoping that they respond to anything that he may add because of who he is – but to make wholesale changes in any shape or form is not going to happen either on or off of the pitch. I would think that most of us would be able to pick at least lets say 16 of the squad right now that will be getting on the plane for Poland.
Simply – there was nobody else that sprung to mind and that was in such a position to be able to take the job. However, for one reason or another the timing of Capello's resignation was awkward. First of all, coming in mid-season as it did and Harry's Spurs challenging to regain a Champions League spot meant that Rednapp probably did not want to leave a job only half done. By sticking with Tottenham – at least until the end of the season means that if he were to become the new nation's manager that he would have little time to prepare for Euro 2012 concentrating on purely England.
In other qualifying countries right now, their managers are 100% focused on what lies ahead this summer and on nothing else. They are talking to all of the top coaches, getting weekly fitness reports, talking to and watching players on a weekly basis that will all figure into their plans this summer. If Rednapp does this, then he literally will only be able to look at a list of players that he already knows and pretty much pick a squad in the same way that the majority of us would.
What is he going to do any differently than anybody else at this stage? What tactics is he going to try and implement in such a short time space for no real preparation? Surely if this is the way that the FA decide to go then Rednapp will be nothing short of just a face this summer being used to just keep the squad ticking over and hoping that they respond to anything that he may add because of who he is – but to make wholesale changes in any shape or form is not going to happen either on or off of the pitch. I would think that most of us would be able to pick at least lets say 16 of the squad right now that will be getting on the plane for Poland.
So if Rednapp does not get the job or only takes the job after this summer then who is going to lead the nation at Euro 2012? Stuart Pearce was put in as caretaker manager for the Dutch friendly game but Pearce has probably got enough on his plate this summer as it is by leading out the British football team for the Olympic Games. There is no disputing Pearce's international record as a player but as a manager at club level, all he has done was a short period in charge at Manchester City. Running the Under 21 team is a far cry from being the full international manager. At a push he could do it but Pearce does not strike me as having the same confidence in the dug out as we saw he had as a player and does not come across fantastically well whenever he is interviewed for the media. He is not as far down the pecking order as Steve McLaren came on the famous night of the umbrella but I can see if England struggle under Pearce it could leave him tarnished for a long time and does he really want that or need that right now?
The other viable English alternatives when Capello was installed as manager were Sam Allardyce and Roy Hodgson. Since then though both have been through some tough times. Big Sam no longer even has a team currently in the Premier League after his unjust sacking by Blackburn and although West Ham have a decent chance of promotion back to the top flight this season, a series of draws and the emergence of Reading have threatened the Hammers automatic promotion possibilities and also drawn criticism of the style of play from the Hammers fans.
Roy Hodgson had just led unfashionable Fulham to a European final and on the back of that was offered the big chair at Anfield. Only half a season later and suffering one of the shortest terms as manager of Liverpool he was sacked and has since picked up the reins at West Brom and has started to turn their fortunes around reasonably well so much so that they are no longer a team in the middle of yet another relegation dog fight. It begs the question though can Hodgson perform as well in the bigger jobs because his track record suggests his effectiveness only becomes efficient when he is in charge of lets say "middle of the road" clubs. Being in the England limelight would be by far the biggest challenge of his career and unfortunately for him his own history suggests that he may well struggle despite being a popular manager at most places that he has been at.
The other viable English alternatives when Capello was installed as manager were Sam Allardyce and Roy Hodgson. Since then though both have been through some tough times. Big Sam no longer even has a team currently in the Premier League after his unjust sacking by Blackburn and although West Ham have a decent chance of promotion back to the top flight this season, a series of draws and the emergence of Reading have threatened the Hammers automatic promotion possibilities and also drawn criticism of the style of play from the Hammers fans.
Roy Hodgson had just led unfashionable Fulham to a European final and on the back of that was offered the big chair at Anfield. Only half a season later and suffering one of the shortest terms as manager of Liverpool he was sacked and has since picked up the reins at West Brom and has started to turn their fortunes around reasonably well so much so that they are no longer a team in the middle of yet another relegation dog fight. It begs the question though can Hodgson perform as well in the bigger jobs because his track record suggests his effectiveness only becomes efficient when he is in charge of lets say "middle of the road" clubs. Being in the England limelight would be by far the biggest challenge of his career and unfortunately for him his own history suggests that he may well struggle despite being a popular manager at most places that he has been at.
That leads me on to the final English candidate that has sprung out of the woodwork so to speak and that man is Glenn Hoddle. A glittering playing career with Spurs saw his twilight years end with roles as player-manager with both Swindon and Chelsea where he continued to be successful and highly popular that when the England job came around the first time he was a natural choice. His England team qualified well for the 1998 World Cup and played reasonably well in the finals before going out of course on penalties (what is new?) to Argentina in a game that many still say to do this day they could of won and then who knows what would have happened?
Hoddle's demise as England manager happened due to events for a change off of the field when some of his religious beliefs were given back page headlines simply because he was the England boss. Once again, it is so typical of this nation's press to go digging that you cannot help but believe who is in charge that the media will eventually dig out some dirt on them. No wonder that the position has been labelled the “poisoned chalice” as these days surely influential managers must look at it and think that it will be the peak of their career but at the same time it will also signal the end of their careers once things start to go wrong and the press jump on the band wagon.
For Hoddle, after leaving the England job he had spells in charge at Spurs, Wolves and Southampton – none of which were particularly successful and since then has only worked mainly in a punditry role in this country whilst attempting to form the Glenn Hoddle Academy for young players . As a pundit Hoddle still shows us that he is still very knowledgable and displays all of the credentials of a man of experience, tactical awareness, confidence and influence that could be a positive attribute in any dressing room. He has also just expressed an interest in the position should there be an opportunity to take it back – perhaps he feels that he has unfinished business there after how it prematurely ended the first time around.
Maybe the FA look at their current predicament as one which is we are damned if we do and damned if we don't and do not have that many top class English options open to them. Yes, they could go abroad again but with so little notice could a foreign manager come in with just a few weeks to go and learn all that they need to know about the English team? If it was a foreign manager already working here such as Arsene Wenger or one that has been here before such as Jose Mourinho then they probably could but anybody else is on a hiding to nothing.
I am not saying that Glenn Hoddle is the best choice for the job right now but he is certainly somebody worth considering seriously. With no club attachment, of course Hoddle is in a position where if appointed he could get to work on it tomorrow without disrupting anybody's season and surely this has to be an important factor for the FA to take into consideration and cannot leave the current situation dangling for much longer – Euro 2012 is just over two months away as it is!
Hoddle's demise as England manager happened due to events for a change off of the field when some of his religious beliefs were given back page headlines simply because he was the England boss. Once again, it is so typical of this nation's press to go digging that you cannot help but believe who is in charge that the media will eventually dig out some dirt on them. No wonder that the position has been labelled the “poisoned chalice” as these days surely influential managers must look at it and think that it will be the peak of their career but at the same time it will also signal the end of their careers once things start to go wrong and the press jump on the band wagon.
For Hoddle, after leaving the England job he had spells in charge at Spurs, Wolves and Southampton – none of which were particularly successful and since then has only worked mainly in a punditry role in this country whilst attempting to form the Glenn Hoddle Academy for young players . As a pundit Hoddle still shows us that he is still very knowledgable and displays all of the credentials of a man of experience, tactical awareness, confidence and influence that could be a positive attribute in any dressing room. He has also just expressed an interest in the position should there be an opportunity to take it back – perhaps he feels that he has unfinished business there after how it prematurely ended the first time around.
Maybe the FA look at their current predicament as one which is we are damned if we do and damned if we don't and do not have that many top class English options open to them. Yes, they could go abroad again but with so little notice could a foreign manager come in with just a few weeks to go and learn all that they need to know about the English team? If it was a foreign manager already working here such as Arsene Wenger or one that has been here before such as Jose Mourinho then they probably could but anybody else is on a hiding to nothing.
I am not saying that Glenn Hoddle is the best choice for the job right now but he is certainly somebody worth considering seriously. With no club attachment, of course Hoddle is in a position where if appointed he could get to work on it tomorrow without disrupting anybody's season and surely this has to be an important factor for the FA to take into consideration and cannot leave the current situation dangling for much longer – Euro 2012 is just over two months away as it is!







RSS Feed